(Bloomberg) -- US President-elect Donald Trump wants to dismantle the federal bureaucracy and even eliminate at least one department. To do that, he’s creating a new agency, called the Department of Government Efficiency.
If the name sounds like a meme, it’s because it is. DOGE is the brainchild of billionaire Elon Musk, who came up with the acronym in homage to the mascot for the digital currency Dogecoin, an object of his obsession.
The ambition is big: $2 trillion in government spending cuts. The overarching goal of a leaner, more efficient government has flummoxed a long line of presidents, both Democrats and Republicans, and the Musk-helmed effort is likely to run into the same political opposition that doomed previous deficit-reduction efforts.
The efficiency effort will be led by two people: Musk and entrepreneur Vivek Ramaswamy, who challenged Trump for the Republican presidential nomination.
Subscribe to the Bloomberg Daybreak podcast on Apple, Spotify or anywhere you listen.
What is the Department of Government Efficiency?
Let’s start with what it isn’t. It’s not a department, because departments are permanent and can only be created — or disbanded — by Congress. Instead, Trump said the group would operate outside of government and disband by July 2026.
But it’s unclear exactly what form it will take, and who will staff and pay for it. One potential mechanism is through the Federal Advisory Committee Act, a 1972 law that allows the president to seek input from committees made up of public- and private-sector participants.
Musk and Ramaswamy seem to envision a more independent structure: “We will serve as outside volunteers, not federal officials or employees,” they wrote in the Wall Street Journal. “Unlike government commissions or advisory committees, we won’t just write reports or cut ribbons. We’ll cut costs.”
Through an account on Musk’s social media platform, DOGE is recruiting “high-IQ small-government revolutionaries” to join the effort.
What are the ethics of this?
Putting Musk and Ramaswamy on a federal advisory committee would make them so-called special government employees. This would subject them to federal ethics laws requiring them to recuse themselves from discussions and decisions impacting them personally. That could complicate things for Musk, whose SpaceX company alone has more than $15 billion in federal contracts. Musk’s companies have also been the target of at least 20 federal regulatory agencies, according to a review conducted by the New York Times.
What’s the goal?
Trump said the group would “provide advice and guidance from outside of Government, and will partner with the White House and Office of Management & Budget to drive large scale structural reform, and create an entrepreneurial approach to Government never seen before.” He called the initiative “The Manhattan Project” of our time, referring to the World War II-era program that led to the development of the atomic bomb.
How much is DOGE looking to cut?
Musk has set a goal of $2 trillion in spending cuts, but it’s unclear whether that’s annual savings or over a 10-year budget window. Trump used an annual figure in his announcement, suggesting it’s the former: “We will drive out the massive waste and fraud which exists throughout our annual $6.5 Trillion Dollars of Government Spending.”
Why hasn’t this been done before?
It has — though never with the backing of the world’s richest man. Washington is littered with spending-reduction plans that never got fully implemented. President Ronald Reagan appointed a 150-member commission headed by chemical company CEO J. Peter Grace to propose cost cuts; most of them were never implemented and the Congressional Budget Office said the savings would be smaller than they appeared. The 2010 Simpson-Bowles commission proposed $4 trillion in cuts over about a decade through delaying the retirement age for Social Security, capping health-care costs and eliminating tax breaks. Congress never acted. Then, a new congressional committee dubbed the Supercommittee attempted to find a “grand bargain” for President Barack Obama and congressional Republicans in 2011. It failed. Multiple government shutdowns and debt-ceiling face-offs that Republicans used to force a budgetary reckoning resulted in short-term fixes. And Trump himself promised in 2016 that he would balance the budget “fairly quickly” but when he left office in 2021, US debt was at a record level.
Why is it so hard?
Serious deficit reduction would require a level of austerity not seen since just after World War II, likely including significant cuts to popular programs such as Social Security, Medicare, Medicaid and veterans’ benefits.
What’s on the chopping block?
Trump has promised to close the Department of Education, turning control of policy and funding back to the states. In their Wall Street Journal op-ed, the duo also named some longtime conservative targets: the Corporation for Public Broadcasting, international organizations and Planned Parenthood.
But much of the cutting would be done through wholesale firings of civil servants — or encouraging them to resign. “Requiring federal employees to come to the office five days a week would result in a wave of voluntary terminations that we welcome: If federal employees don’t want to show up, American taxpayers shouldn’t pay them for the Covid-era privilege of staying home,” they wrote.
What about waste, fraud and abuse?
Trump said the commission would target “massive waste and fraud.” This has long been a mantra of conservative politicians, while efforts to achieve it have had mixed results. The Government Accountability Office estimates that federal agencies lose between $233 billion and $521 billion to fraud every year. The biggest culprit has been the Covid-19 spending packages that Trump signed into law in 2020; a 2023 Associated Press review found that 10% of the $4.2 trillion in pandemic relief had been misspent. Waste is more subjective. Since 2011, the GAO has sent Congress 14 reports containing 2,018 recommendations to reduce or eliminate duplicate programs or reduce costs in the federal government. Congress has adopted about two-thirds of them, saving about $667.5 billion.
How will the public know what DOGE is proposing?
Federal law requires advisory committee meetings to be open and Musk has promised that all actions would be “posted online for maximum transparency.” He’s also hinted there could be some game-like public input. “We will also have a leader board for most insanely dumb spending of your tax dollars. This will be both extremely tragic and extremely entertaining,” he said.
Can Trump do this without Congress?
Trump doesn’t need Congress to approve Musk’s role, but Congress holds the spending power under the Constitution and would have to approve any cuts. Trump, however, thinks he’s found a workaround. He plans to challenge a key provision of a 1974 law that forms the basis of the modern federal budget process. That provision, known as the Impoundment Control Act, says the president must spend money that’s appropriated unless Congress decides to rescind it, that is, he can’t impound it. “Bringing back impoundment will give us a crucial tool with which to obliterate the deep state, drain the swamp, and starve the warmongers,” Trump said last year. “With impoundment, we can simply choke off the money.”
©2024 Bloomberg L.P.